Joseph Z. Amsel
Rated by Super Lawyers


loading ...
top of page

Recent Trial Success

  • Client facing mandatory minimum of 5 years and maximum of 25 years in prison found NOT GUILTY by jury of Attempted Murder in the Second Degree after Mr. Amsel successfully argued that client acted in self-defense when he stabbed the complainant.

  • Client facing mandatory minimum of 3 ½ years and a maximum of 15 years found NOT GUILTY by jury of Attempted Assault in the First Degree and Criminal Possession of a Weapon in the Second Degree in connection with a shooting despite client being photographed by the alleged victim holding a firearm and there being video surveillance of the client holding what appeared to be a firearm. 

  • Client facing mandatory minimum of 5 years and a maximum of 25 years found NOT GUILTY of all charges by jury of Attempted Murder in the Second Degree and all other charges in connection with a shooting after Mr. Amsel successfully argued that the alleged victims fabricated their claim that the Client was the shooter. 

  • Client facing 16 years to life in prison as a persistent violent felony offender found NOT GUILTY by jury of Burglary in the Second Degree after Mr. Amsel successfully argues that the complainant misidentified client as the burglar he confronted inside his home.

  • Trial of Client facing 16 years to life in prison for Burglary in the Second Degree ends in an evenly split Hung Jury after Mr. Amsel successfully argues that the prosecution’s DNA expert, who claimed that the DNA evidence taken from a blood sample on the windowsill of the complainant’s home matched the client’s DNA, was incredible. 

  • Client facing mandatory minimum of 7 years and maximum of 15 years found NOT GUILTY by jury of Criminal Possession of a Weapon in Second Degree and Domestic Violence Assault after Mr. Amsel successfully argues that the prosecution failed to prove that Defendant possessed a firearm that his ex-girlfriend claimed belonged to him, despite his DNA being on the firearm. 

  • Client facing mandatory minimum of 7 years and maximum of 15 years in prison found NOT GUILTY of Criminal Possession of a Weapon in Second Degree after Mr. Amsel successfully argues that the prosecution failed to prove that Client possessed the firearm that was recovered from the road where the Client ran by while fleeing from the police. 

  • Client facing mandatory minimum of 3 ½ years and maximum of 15 years in prison found NOT GUILTY of Criminal Possession of a Weapon in Second Degree after Mr. Amsel successfully argues that the prosecution failed to prove that the Client knew of the firearm inside the vehicle, which was a community "Dollar Van."

  • Client facing a mandatory minimum of 8 years and maximum of 25 years in prison found NOT GUILTY of Assault on a Police Officer despite the prosecution presenting evidence that the Client bit a police officer’s finger off after Mr. Amsel successfully argued that the police lacked a lawful basis to stop, question and attempt to arrest the Client. 

  • Trial of Client facing 25 years to life in prison as a persistent violent felony offender ends in a Hung Jury with 11 of the 12 jurors voting to acquit the client of Attempted Murder in the Second Degree and Strangulation, despite the prosecution presenting a video purportedly depicting the Client on top of the complainant while she lay unconscious and unresponsive.

  • Client facing mandatory minimum of 10 years and a maximum of 25 years in prison found NOT GUILTY of shooting and drug charges after Mr. Amsel dismantles the cooperating witness on cross-examination and establishes that the police unlawfully attributed drugs recovered from the cooperator to the Client. 

  • Client facing mandatory minimum of 7 years and a maximum of 15 years in prison found NOT GUILTY of Criminal Possession of a Weapon in the Second Degree (intent to use unlawfully against another) despite loaded firearm being recovered from Client's person.  

  • Client found NOT GUILTY of Domestic Violence Assault charges after Mr. Amsel successfully argues that the complainant’s story was incredible. 

  • Client found NOT GUILTY of Stalking in the Third Degree despite prosecution presenting evidence of numerous messages and calls allegedly sent by Client to his ex-girlfriend.  

Recent Federal Criminal Defense Success 

  • Client charged in the District of New Jersey receives a sentence of Time Served on Drug Conspiracy after Mr. Amsel successfully argues that Client should have received jail credit for the time he served on an unrelated case due to the Government’s failure to bring the charges in a timely manner.

  • Client charged in the Eastern District of New York with Aggravated Identity Theft and Wire Fraud avoids jail time in long term investigation involving individuals working for the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner accused of stealing credit cards from deceased individuals.

  • Client facing a Guideline range of over ten years receives a sentence of 1 year, a below Guideline Range sentence, in complex Drug Conspiracy due to Mr. Amsel successful advocacy centering on the client’s family circumstances, including being the primary caretaker of his young daughter.

  • Client charged in the District of New Jersey receives below-Guideline sentence in complex gun and drug trafficking case.

  • Client charged in the District of New Jersey with gun possession and drug conspiracy receives a below-Guideline sentence.

  • Client facing complex Federal securities fraud investigation avoids all charges.

Recent Dismissals and Favorable Plea Deals

  • Client facing mandatory minimum of 7 years and a maximum of 15 years has gun charges dismissed after Mr. Amsel successfully argues that the People’s Certificate of Compliance was illusory.

  • Client facing mandatory minimum of 3 ½ years and maximum of 15 years has gun charges dismissed after Mr. Amsel successfully argues that the People’s certificate of compliance was illusory.

  • Client facing mandatory minimum of 5 years and maximum of 25 years has indictment dismissed after Mr. Amsel successfully moves to dismiss based on the fact that the evidence before the grand jury was legally insufficient. 

  • Client facing 14 to 28 years in prison for seven incidents of felony criminal contempt gets misdemeanor plea after Mr. Amsel discovers that the complainant fabricated the charges.

  • Client, a college basketball player, facing mandatory minimum of 3 ½ years and a maximum of 15 years in prison for gun possession has gun charges dismissed after Mr. Amsel is able to establish that the Client knew nothing of the firearm that was on the person of one of the occupants inside her car. Client was able to resume her college basketball career. 

  • Client facing 7 years in prison and loss of professional license has all charged dismissed.

  • Client facing 20 years on fraud, larceny and gun charges has all felonies dismissed.

  • Client facing mandatory minimum of 5 years and a maximum of 25 years for acting as the getaway driver to a shooting that was part of a complex gang conspiracy case is the only defendant of nearly 30 defendants who receives no jail time after Mr. Amsel obtained her release from prison on a writ of habeas corpus to the Appellate Division, Second Department.

  • Client facing up 7 years in prison gets disorderly conduct after Mr. Amsel is able to obtain a mental health treatment program for Client.

  • Client facing mandatory minimum of 5 years and a maximum of 15 years has all felonies dismissed and gets a plea of a misdemeanor trespass and time served to resolve residential burglary charges.

  • Client facing charges of aiding others in stealing baggage at the airport is able to avoid all charges after Mr. Amsel successfully convinces prosecutor that Client lacked criminal intent. 

  • Client facing a maximum of life in prison for drug charges avoids all jail time on complex drug conspiracy.

  • Client facing a mandatory minimum of 3 ½ to 15 years in prison for gun possession at the airport while working for TSA obtains plea deal involving weekend incarceration despite client being caught on airport cameras posing the firearm and discarding it.

  • Client facing mandatory minimum of 3 ½ years and maximum of 15 years in prison on rape charges has felonies dismissed and receives no jail time on misdemeanor plea deal after Mr. Amsel successfully showed the prosecutor that the complainant lacked credibility due to his meticulous investigation.

  • Client facing 7 years in prison on gun charges has all charges dismissed

  • Client facing 25 years in prison avoids all criminal charges in complex securities fraud scheme.

  • Client facing 37 years on multiple burglary and assault cases in two counties has all felony charges dismissed.

  • Client facing mandatory prison term on felony larceny charges and a violation of probation has all felony charges dismissed and avoids probation violation. 

  • Client facing gun charges gets misdemeanor plea after Mr. Amsel successfully establishes that gun was inoperable.

  • Client facing deportation due to domestic violence case has all charges dismissed, enabling him to petition to for release from ICE custody.

  • Client facing termination of child custody due to felony child-abuse charges has all criminal charges dismissed.

  • Client facing mandatory deportation for drug conviction has conviction vacated after the Mr. Amsel successfully proved at a hearing, held after filing a CPL § 440.10 motion, that the client was deprived of his constitutional right to effective assistance of counsel at the time of his plea. 

Recent Personal Injury and Civil Rights Success

  • Client obtains six-figure recovery after trial verdict in motorcycle accident finding defendant caused client's permanent injuries to neck and shoulder.  

  • Client obtains settlement of $650,000 after suffering neck, shoulder and knee injuries in car accident. 

  • Client who was falsely arrested by police awarded $35,000 for one hour in custody.

  • Client awarded $100,000 within two months of car accident after Mr. Amsel prove to the insurance company that the defendant was 100% responsible for the accident.  

  • Client awarded $100,000 after defective glass door that fell on her injuring her wrist.  

  • Client obtains six-figure award after jury finds defendant 100% responsible for Client’s neck, back and knee injuries.  

  • Client obtains six-figure award after trial verdict in trip and fall case in supermarket where client suffered neck and back injuries. 

bottom of page